Best American Restaurant in Wallingford, CT

Q: What are you known for?

We are known for Crab, Salmon, Tuna Salad Sandwich, Pulled Pork, Fries, Fried Calamari, Oyster, Jambalaya, Oysters, Shrimp Cocktail, Fish, Pasta, Shrimp, Calamari, Pancakes, Onion Rings, Frittata, Cheesesteak, Garden Burger, Chili, Crab Cakes, Fried Shrimp, Waffles, Soup, Hangover Burger, Caesar Salad, Gluten Free, Brunch, Hot Dogs, Chicken Sandwich, American Food, Burgers, Sandwiches, Chicken Wings, Prime Rib, Pizza, Slider, Meatloaf, Lobster Rolls, Pot Roast, Sriracha Burger, Seafood, Cheeseburger, Chicken Tenders, Grilled Cheese, Sliders, Jalapeno Poppers, Chicken Salad, Wings, Lobster Roll, Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Salads, Belgian Waffles, Lobster, Chicken Pot Pie, Sweet Potato Fries, Deli Sandwiches, Quesadilla, Philly Cheesesteak, and Cioppino

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in **Wallingford, CT** at **40 N Main St**

Your Favorite Local Hangout for Delicious, Exceptional Food and Good Times

Order online

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Gaetano’s Tavern On Main

Gaetano’s Tavern On Main is your go-to spot in Wallingford, CT, for good food, great drinks, and friendly company. Located at 40 North Main Street, our neighborhood tavern offers a comfortable space where everyone feels welcome. Enjoy classic American favorites, from hearty entrees to shareable appetizers, all made fresh and served with care.

Food, Drinks & Good Times

Our menu is packed with classic American comfort food, perfect for any mood or occasion. Pair your meal with one of our drinks from the bar and settle in for a great time. Whether it’s a casual night out, a quick lunch, or a laid-back weekend hangout, you’ll always find a warm welcome here.

Explore Our Menu

Order From Our Website

You’re just a click away. Order from our website for quick delivery or easy pickup. Fresh, hot, and ready when you are.

Order Now

Happy Hour!!

Join us Monday - Friday, 4:00 pm - 6:00 pm for our $10 & Under Happy Hour. Offering great food and drinks at a reasonable price!

Order online

Award-Winning Flavor 🏆

We’re proud to be voted #1 in the Reader’s Choice Awards for Best American Dining! This honor means the world to us and reflects our commitment to serving delicious food with exceptional service every day. Thank you to our amazing guests for making us your top choice!

Gaetano's in the Press

Your Place for Every Occasion

Planning a get-together? Come meet your friends in our casual dining area and enjoy great food, refreshing drinks, and exceptional service in a relaxed atmosphere.

Comfortable Casual Bar Area

Step into our inviting bar room and experience the perfect blend of comfort and great service from our attentive bartenders, while enjoying a delicious meal, ranging from sandwiches to entrees, and watching your favorite game on one of our six TVs.

Order online

Featuring

Catering

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Vegetarian Options

Happy hour food

Great cocktails

Delivery

Takeout

Visit Us Soon 📍

Come see what makes us a local favorite! Stop by 40 North Main Street in Wallingford, CT, and enjoy great food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re dining in, picking up your order, or just grabbing a drink, we’re always ready to serve you. Your table’s waiting—visit us today!

What our guests are saying

A very pleasant experience I, my wife and Eddie( dog) had at Gaetano's Tavern. It was a beautiful afternoon with outdoor dining Summer is the best time of year at Gaetano’s Tavern on Main. The Soft Shell Crab, Fried Oysters and Whole Belly Clams are phenomenal. Or choose anything on the menu. You won’t be disappointed. Yum!

Mike M.

Wonderful spot with delicious cuisine and amazing staff! Our waitress Jill was the best - knowledgeable of the menu and very attentive. The drinks were incredible - especially the espresso martini! It was an amazing, memorable Valentines Day experience. Can’t wait to come back!